For some reason, I've found myself reading a lot of radlib books this summer. This book, despite claiming to be leftist, certainly earns its spot with the other radlib books I've read. As my title says it is terminally capitalist realist in that even when it acknowledges the failures of postwar social democracy and correctly articulates that it failed because it gave the bourgeoise time to fight back against it, this book argues that a return to such a system, albeit with a lower consumption rate, is the best that we can hope for. Furthermore, although it correctly notes that degrowth is antithetical to capitalism, it still advocates for social democracy as a means for degrowth because then the capitalism will be "regulated". Finally, it advocates for class collaboration because "the bourgeoise will be affected by climate change too" and seems outright hostile to the idea of an organic working-class …
Reviews and Comments
Love me books, love me FOSS, love me socialism, love me tea. Simple as.
This link opens in a pop-up window
Kantolope reviewed Post-Growth Living by Kate Soper
Terminal Capitalist Realism
1 star
For some reason, I've found myself reading a lot of radlib books this summer. This book, despite claiming to be leftist, certainly earns its spot with the other radlib books I've read. As my title says it is terminally capitalist realist in that even when it acknowledges the failures of postwar social democracy and correctly articulates that it failed because it gave the bourgeoise time to fight back against it, this book argues that a return to such a system, albeit with a lower consumption rate, is the best that we can hope for. Furthermore, although it correctly notes that degrowth is antithetical to capitalism, it still advocates for social democracy as a means for degrowth because then the capitalism will be "regulated". Finally, it advocates for class collaboration because "the bourgeoise will be affected by climate change too" and seems outright hostile to the idea of an organic working-class movement for ecological sustainability. The previous points aside, were I a professor marking this book as a monograph, I would have to say that it failed. This is not because it is poorly written, but because it fails at every opportunity to prove or even defend its thesis. The central thesis of the book is that we can argue for degrowth on hedonist grounds because consumer society makes people unhappy. All well and good. However, the book does not give a single example of how a society based on degrowth would make people happier, and just assumes that the reader will agree that it would. This sucks because I do agree that a society based on degrowth would be both more fulfilling and more hedonically desireable. However, I can't reccommend this book to someone on the fence about these issues because there is no argument regarding this claim. Do yourself a favour and give this book a pass in favour of a better book on degrowth.
Kantolope commented on Post-Growth Living by Kate Soper
Kantolope commented on Post-Growth Living by Kate Soper
This criticism of posthumamism is Engels-tier "Oh, you say you want to erode the boundaries between the human and the non-human, but you refer to humans as a distinct concept. Curious." It doesn't have much to do with the main thesis of the book, so I don't mind that much, but man is it bad.
Kantolope reviewed Winter Herald by Jordan Heeren
Excellent Fantasy
5 stars
I always love reading indie fiction because there's always the chance that I could stumble onto something amazing that could never be published in today's publishing industry. Winter Herald, and the earlier book in the series, Shadow Herald, are one such occasion. These books really have everything that I'm looking for in a fantasy novel. Relatable characters, compelling plot, a conlang, revolution against the oppresive social order, and a great queer romance. Also, regarding that, the romance is excellent. As a caveat, I'm ace, so I don't really go in for romance, but the dynamic between Navaeli and Chrislie is so wholesome and supportive that I really can't find a single thing wrong with it. There's no contrived drama that makes me think that the characters would be better off on their own, just two ladies genuinely loving and supporting each other. I reccommend these books to just about everyone …
I always love reading indie fiction because there's always the chance that I could stumble onto something amazing that could never be published in today's publishing industry. Winter Herald, and the earlier book in the series, Shadow Herald, are one such occasion. These books really have everything that I'm looking for in a fantasy novel. Relatable characters, compelling plot, a conlang, revolution against the oppresive social order, and a great queer romance. Also, regarding that, the romance is excellent. As a caveat, I'm ace, so I don't really go in for romance, but the dynamic between Navaeli and Chrislie is so wholesome and supportive that I really can't find a single thing wrong with it. There's no contrived drama that makes me think that the characters would be better off on their own, just two ladies genuinely loving and supporting each other. I reccommend these books to just about everyone and I am eagerly anticipating the next book in the series. Plus, the books are just $5 on the author's itch.io page (gailywriting.itch.io). It's hard to beat that price!
Kantolope started reading Shadow Herald by Jordan Heeren
Kantolope finished reading Corvus by Harold Johnson
This is like the most radlib sci-fi book I've ever read. It straight up says that capitalism will be the cause of environmental collapse and mass death, but also that there are no alternatives, while simultaneously portraying alternatives in the text itself which seem to work fine. It also has a weirdly anprim stance on technology, stating that technology itself is bad and environmentally harmful and completely ignores the social and political context in which that technology is developed. All in all, I do not recommend.
Kantolope commented on Corvus by Harold Johnson
Kantolope finished reading Shady Hollow by Juneau Black (Shady Hollow, #1)
Kantolope commented on The Ruthless Lady's Guide to Wizardry by C. M. Waggoner
Kantolope commented on The Ruthless Lady's Guide to Wizardry by C. M. Waggoner
Kantolope commented on The Ruthless Lady's Guide to Wizardry by C. M. Waggoner
Kantolope finished reading Dune by Frank Herbert
Kantolope reviewed Think like a Commoner by David Bollier
An Excellent Guide to Commoning
5 stars
This is a wonderful little book about what the commons are, why they are important, and how they can and must be protected. If you're an anarchist, this is required reading. If you're some variety of non-anarchist socialist, this is still important, because although it's not workers' control (commons operate separately from employment) the commons are a great way to build dual power, and put power back in the hands of the common people. It even mentions the Free Software community by name as an example of a commons, so if you're reading this review, then you're already commoning. One potential criticism is that it isn't very academic, but to be honest, I don't think that matters that much. It's not trying to be an academic study of the commons, just a short introduction on how you can work the commons into your everyday life.
Kantolope reviewed As We Have Always Done by Leanne Betasamosake Simpson (Indigenous Americas)
Fantastic Guide for Resurgent and Revolutionary Praxis
5 stars
If you live in a settler-colonial country, especially Canada, you need to read this book. If you don't live in a settler colonial country but want to build relationships for emancipation with globally oppressed minorities, this book provides a great guide to do that too. There's really nobody I wouldn't recommend this book to. Even your racist uncle will hopefully get a wakeup call from Simpson's amazingly thoughtful and insightful text.









