Reviews and Comments

elisabeth nicula

elisabeth@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 years, 7 months ago

luv 2 read

This link opens in a pop-up window

Pirates of the Chesapeake Bay (Paperback, 2020, The History Press) 2 stars

The story of Chesapeake pirates and patriots begins with a land dispute and ends with …

"Before they could even reach them, the Victoria J. Peed temporarily ran aground..."

2 stars

Not really that great ha ha but worth a read if you're really into knowing everything about the Chesapeake Bay. I was hoping for a contextualized, history-from-below approach and it is more of a straight account of various pirate activities with detailed lists of the value of various booty and so on. The Oyster Wars part is pretty decent—perhaps being the most recent it has the most context.

Pure America (Hardcover, 2021, Belt Publishing) 4 stars

Between 1927 and 1979, more than 8,000 people were involuntarily sterilized in five hospitals across …

"$700,000. This is how much the regret for fifty-five years of eugenics costs in the state of Virginia."

4 stars

I found this one both terribly eye-opening and slightly unfocused. Still, would recommend, and it's a quick read. Catte covers a lot of ground, beginning with Carrie Buck of Charlottesville and the grotesque events (including SCOTUS show trial) that led to her forced sterilization at the Lynchburg Colony. There is a brief history of eugenicist thought in the U.S.; a revisitation of the Shenandoah National Park section of What You Are Getting Wrong About Appalachia; a pretty pleasurable skewering of UVa; and an inquiry into the mixed up architectural and eugenic history of Western State Hospital in Staunton, as viewed through its current rehabilitation by real estate developers. Pure America really zings when Catte makes obvious the underlying truths about labor—like that the fundamental point of sterilizing women like Carrie Buck was to send them to work in the homes of rich Virginians without the possibility of their being embarrassingly …

WOMEN (1998, Farrar, Straus and Giroux) 5 stars

A New York Times Notable Book

Daring and fiercely original, The Women is at once …

"I have not catapulted myself past my mother's emotional existence."

5 stars

Feel pretty devastated!! Feel unable to "review!" Als has an uncommon ability to know (or guess at) the interiority of others, and his own, and to describe it. Weirdly light moment for me was when some of the characters from Please Kill Me came back through in the essay about Dorothy Dean.

Baby, I Don't Care (Hardcover, 2018, Wave Books) 4 stars

Chelsey Minnis's new collection of poems follows the struggle of a flawed character in a …

"Look, it's been very hard to puppeteer myself / all these years!"

4 stars

Extravagant, funny, disturbed poetry, forming a narrative in one voice and one repeating structure through the book. Kinda like if a dissolute young 50s housewife was going out of her mind today? A love story but most often not very loving? Idk I thought it was pretty pleasurable and surprising.

Time Is the Thing a Body Moves Through (Paperback, 2019, Coffee House Press) 4 stars

How do the bodies we inhabit affect our relationship with art? How does art affect …

"It's taken a lot of resistance, that I want to leave my gender and my sex life uninscribed—that it took me years to consider the fact that I did not have to name my gender or sexuality at all"

4 stars

I had a weird-for-me experience of really enjoying this book while having several critical feelings about the writing. I think because it's experimental and meandering, with verse sections and fragmentation, and I wanted them to push on those aspects harder. Many beautiful/dirty images and thoughts and moments and I would recommend it. Maybe too obvious a comparison but I found it interesting to read this after having read Paul Takes the Form of a Mortal Girl. Both situate a gender/sex narrative amidst cultural artifacts—for Paul, mostly 80s and 90s alt-pop music, and for Time, Felix Gonzales-Torres's and Roni Horn's sculptures—and the formal outcome of each book seems to turn on (or at least relate to) those choices.

Drifts (2020, Penguin Publishing Group) 4 stars

A restlessly brilliant novel of creative crisis and transformation

Beguiling and compulsively readable, Drifts is …

"People always say that about art, or any form of keeping time, of collecting."

4 stars

Felt neat to read someone with the same apparent preoccupations as me—taking the same photo over and over, for one. I think she would have been writing it in 2016 but in its fragmentation, and sometimes panicked, sometimes restful contemplation, very much feels like a quarantine novel. Was nice to feel like I was in New York, seeing art, walking around, reading.

Tender Points (Paperback, 2019, Nightboat Books) 5 stars

"Tender Points is a narrative fractured by trauma. Named after the diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia, …

"My body is writing this and it's in pain."

5 stars

Tender Points was originally published in 2015 and in the intervening years its topics—sexual violence, chronic illness, and inequalities of medical care—have been much in the public psyche. I found this quiet, furious account to be emotionally re-situating. Pain and place and the expression and experience of art all tangled up together, as it is.